Skip to content

Freshmen Run Away From Obama

The House Democratic freshmen who rose to power riding then-candidate Barack Obama’s coattails are now eager to strut their independence heading into the midterms.

Some rookies opposed Obama’s cap-and-trade climate change bill; others rejected his health care plan. But even those Members who backed all of the president’s signature initiatives are ready to show that they can win their first re-election bids without leaning on Obama’s star power.

“You have to be an independent, no matter what,” Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper said. The Pennsylvania Democrat pointed to her vote against the climate change bill, which she said is an economic loser for southwest Pennsylvania, and her fight for abortion funding restrictions in the health care bill as evidence of her independence.

Dahlkemper said that while she would be “very happy to welcome” Obama to her district, she didn’t know how much of a help or a hindrance he would be.

“I just think we don’t quite know yet where his popularity is,” she said.

“The best thing I can do is get out and shake hands and look people in the eye,” she said. “They want to see me and they want to know what I’m doing. … I’m much less concerned about who’s going to come in and campaign for me.”

Rep. Betsy Markey, who voted against the House health care bill but ultimately voted for the final plan, said she didn’t think it would make much difference either way if the president stumped in her district.

“It’s always an honor when the president makes an offer to visit. But this is a Colorado race,” the Democrat said.

Nearly all freshman Democrats embraced Obama’s broad economic plan as soon as they came to office — and that includes last year’s $787 billion stimulus package that cut taxes and increased spending in an unprecedented effort to blunt the recession. Republicans have been aggressively attacking Democrats for that vote ever since, accusing them of endorsing out-of-control Washington spending while failing to stay focused on jobs and the economy.

In an e-mail sent Friday to the districts of more than a dozen freshman Democrats, National Republican Congressional Committee Communications Director Ken Spain blasted them for “running scared” from their state’s unemployment problems and cited the “failed trillion-dollar stimulus flop” as proof that they are out of touch.

But first-term Democrats may be looking at newly minted Rep. Mark Critz for inspiration. The Pennsylvania Democrat performed better than expected in last week’s special election to replace the late Rep. John Murtha (D) — and he did so by running as an independent-minded Democrat who is pro-gun, anti-abortion and against Obama’s health care plan.

“At the end of the day, each of us is judged by what we’ve done,” Rep. Tom Perriello said.

Obama didn’t carry the Virginia Democrat’s district in 2008, but Perriello has voted for all of the president’s signature issues. He said he is “proud to have stood with him” on legislation he agreed with and would welcome a joint appearance with the president in his district — even though some of his constituents may not be Obama’s biggest fans.

“It might upset some people. Probably the same people who weren’t real crazy about me either,” Perriello said.

Rep. Frank Kratovil, a freshman from a district Obama lost by 18 points, said his victory proved that people vote for the individual and don’t necessarily base their votes on a party or a president.

“Everyone views us as the pawns of things we can’t control,” the Maryland Democrat said. “Ultimately these things are decisions about two or three people.”

And while Kratovil has staked out areas of independence — he voted against health care reform but for cap-and-trade — he sees no advantage in attacking Obama, either.

“I have never been one to believe in throwing other people under the bus to make yourself look better. I don’t agree with [Obama] on everything, but there are things I do. I am my own guy. … I think overall the president’s done the best job he can given the incredible difficult situation he found himself in.”

Freshmen in states hit the hardest by the recession say they are eager to focus on the work they have done for their constituents, while also bashing Republicans for having no solutions, saying it was the GOP that fell asleep at the switch when the economy crashed under then-President George W. Bush.

Rep. Steve Driehaus (D-Ohio) said that while he doesn’t agree with Obama on some issues, he welcomes the president to his Cincinnati district because it gives him a chance to draw comparisons between Obama’s and Bush’s economic policies.

“I will compare Bush to Obama any day of the week,” he said.

Fellow Ohio Democratic Rep. John Boccieri said he has already had Obama come to Ohio as part of his push for health care reform and was among the freshmen who voted for health care and climate change legislation. But he said his focus will be on results, not politicians.

“The face of this debate is not Nancy Pelosi, Barack Obama or Harry Reid, it was Jack Hillyer from my Congressional district, who lost his health insurance even though he had a motorcycle dealership, and he sat in my office almost in tears and said, ‘Congressman, I hope I can live for two years so I can get on Medicare,'” he said.

Recent Stories

Lee, Fitzpatrick win primaries as fall matchups set in PA

Aid finally set to flow as Senate clears $95.3B emergency bill

Flag fracas: Republicans ‘infuriated’ by show of support for Ukraine  

Justice Department settles claims on USA Gymnastics investigation

Senate looks to clear aid bill Tuesday night with no amendments

‘Cruelty and chaos’: Biden hits Trump in Florida over abortion bans