Senate Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer unveiled draft legislation Wednesday that would decriminalize cannabis and expunge federal sentences tied to the drug, which has been legalized in states across the country.
The bill would erase the records of nonviolent marijuana offenders and allow those currently serving time to petition a court for resentencing. Federal tax revenues would support a trust fund to reinvest in communities most affected by enforcement involving the drug.
Advocates were split over aspects of the bill, which is co-sponsored by Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., and Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore. Polling indicates the vast majority of Americans support the legalization of marijuana in some form, and the issue has especially gained steam among advocates for treating veterans’ mental health issues.
“As my colleagues and I have said before, the war on drugs has really been a war on people, particularly people of color,” Schumer said.
Booker highlighted the hypocrisy of congressional and presidential candidates readily admitting their history of marijuana use while low-income people and people of color bear “the stain” of criminal convictions.
“This is a grievous reality,” he said. “Lives are being destroyed every single day.”
Schumer said the next step would be to gather feedback from interest groups, many of which were quick to weigh in Wednesday.
“It is time for legislators to comport federal law with the laws of the growing number of states that have legalized the plant, and it is time for lawmakers to facilitate a federal structure that allows for cannabis commerce so that responsible consumers can obtain high-quality, low-cost cannabis grown right here in America without fear of arrest and incarceration,” Erik Altieri, executive director of advocacy group NORML, said in a statement.
Maritza Perez, national affairs director of the Drug Policy Alliance, urged lawmakers to drop provisions maintaining drug tests for federal employees and excluding those who received “kingpin” convictions from expunging their records.
“In order for this bill to truly end marijuana prohibition in a comprehensive way and begin to repair the egregious harms of the past, we cannot continue to make room for some to be left out because of laws that were unjust and racist to begin with,” she said in a statement.
But another group, Smart Approaches to Marijuana, urged a more deliberate approach.
“Decriminalization of minor marijuana possession and expungement of previous records was a key part of President Joe Biden’s platform and should be the path forward, but we cannot let the interests of the for-profit marijuana industry and its investors cloud the discussion,” said Kevin Sabet, the organization’s president and a former Obama administration senior drug policy adviser. “Much as we have done with COVID, we must heed the science and be cautious with normalizing and promoting marijuana use.”
Details of the draft
The bill would end years of contradictory federal rules in states that legalized cannabis and would implement regulations on a booming marijuana market for the first time. To date, recreational marijuana is legal for adult use in 18 states, Washington, D.C., Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands. Medicinal use is legal in 37 states, Washington, D.C., Puerto Rico, Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Under the draft bill, people would no longer be at risk of deportation because of cannabis use. Health care providers with the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Indian Health Service could prescribe medical marijuana.
The bill would not override laws in states where marijuana remains illegal, and it would maintain bans on transporting large amounts of marijuana into those states.
The legislation would levy a 10 percent excise tax on cannabis products in the first full year of enactment, which would gradually rise to 25 percent thereafter. The government would attempt to make amends for the war on drugs by investing those revenues in legal aid, reentry services and business loans.
The comptroller general would be tasked with studying further areas in need of change, including whether to replace the word marijuana with cannabis in the federal code in an attempt to reduce stigma.
Some products would still be outlawed, including items that combine cannabis with alcohol, caffeine or nicotine. Electronic delivery, or vaping, devices would be prohibited from offering flavors, in an apparent attempt to avoid a repeat of the teen vaping epidemic partially fueled by e-cigarette marketing.
The draft leaves some open questions about how marijuana should be regulated, including how potency levels would be measured and whether new marijuana products should undergo premarket review by the Food and Drug Administration before they hit store shelves.
Despite the high-powered support among top lawmakers, the legislation faces significant hurdles. Biden’s decadeslong opposition to legalization presents one obstacle to enacting Schumer’s bill. Though the president supported decriminalizing marijuana possession on the campaign trail, news broke in March that the White House sidelined young staffers for prior marijuana use.
“The White House knows we are introducing this legislation, and we intend to show them the draft legislation and ask them to support it,” Schumer said Wednesday.
In April, Schumer told Politico that he would not wait for the president’s backing to advance the bill in the Senate.
Sen. Charles E. Grassley, R-Iowa, said Democrats’ effort amounted to putting “the cart before the horse,” adding that his previous research bill with Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., should be used as the first step toward full legalization.
“It’s important that we have robust research and fully understand the good and the bad of marijuana use, especially in young people and over the long term,” he said in a statement.
Late last year, the House passed a bill that would remove marijuana from the federal schedule of controlled substances and redress the war on drugs through similar criminal justice changes, social services investments and business loans. The bill was reintroduced by House Judiciary Chairman Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., in May.
House lawmakers are also seeking to facilitate research for Schedule I drugs in the Department of Health and Human Services appropriations bill. The House Appropriations Committee is expected to approve the bill Thursday after a subcommittee advanced it Monday.
Sandhya Raman contributed to this report.