Skip to content

Fact-Checking ‘Veep’ Season 5

Here's your Constitution refresher for the day

Courtesy HBO
Courtesy HBO

The fifth season of HBO’s ‘Veep’ managed to create more electoral chaos than the country has seen and gave viewers a Constitution refresher.  

Congress electing the president has only really happened twice in history — 1800 and 1824. In the last election, the National Constitution Center predicted  that such an event would result in a Mitt Romney presidency with Joseph R. Biden Jr. as vice president.

Here’s how that could happen

In the wake of the confusing 1800 election, Congress ratified the 12th Amendment , which laid out what would happen in the event of a tie.  

It reads, “The House of Representatives shall choose immediately, by ballot, the President” and “the Senate shall choose the vice president.”  

All representatives within a given state vote as a bloc with each state having one vote, determined by the majority of votes in the bloc.  

If the House fails to decide, the vice president acts as president.  

The amendment reads, “If the House of Representatives shall not choose a president whenever the right of choice shall devolve upon them, before the fourth day of March next following, then the vice president shall act as president, as in case of the death or other constitutional disability of the president.”  

Remember: This was before the 20th Amendment moved the start of a new session of Congress to January.

Spoiler alert

In “Veep’s” fifth season, Selina Meyer (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) failed to receive the 270 electoral votes needed to win. She helped get Jonah Ryan (Timothy Simons) a New Hampshire congressional seat to give her an extra vote in the House. But, three states abstained in the House vote which meant that neither Meyer nor her opponent ended up with a majority.   

So with the presidency still vacant, the Senate vote on vice president should determine who will be president. And (stop reading if you haven’t seen the season finale), there’s a tie in the Senate. So, the president of the Senate — the sitting vice president — breaks the tie for vice president.  

In this case — stay with me — Meyer’s sitting vice president (Andrew Doyle played by Phil Reeves) votes against her vice president on the new re-election ticket (Tom James played by Hugh Laurie) because he was promised secretary of State by the other vice presidential candidate (Laura Montez played by Andrea Savage).  

Even stranger, a real-life split White House in 2012 could have happened if the Electoral College vote ended in a tie. After the 2012 election, Republicans ran the House and would likely have elected Romney as president. But, Democrats ran the Senate and would likely have selected Biden as vice president.

History lesson

In 1800, Thomas Jefferson was the Democratic-Republican candidate and Aaron Burr was his vice presidential candidate. Jefferson and Burr each received 73 electoral votes for president so the decision fell to the lame duck Congress at the time.  

The House elected Jefferson over his running mate, Burr. The 12th  Amendment then decided electors would vote separately for president and vice president.  

In 1824, a split among four candidates caused no one to get the majority. Andrew Jackson won the popular vote with about 41 percent but third place, Henry Clay, agreed to support John Quincy Adams, second place, in exchange for Secretary of State. So with Clay’s sway, the House chose Adams as president.  

Let’s see if 2016 can top HBO’s fictional election.

Get breaking news alerts and more from Roll Call on your iPhone or your Android.

Recent Stories

White House rattles its saber with warnings to Iran, China about attacking US allies

Photos of the week ending April 12, 2024

We must support Ukraine: Future generations will thank us

House looks to try again on surveillance authority reauthorization

New House Appropriations cardinals slate starts to take shape

Capitol Lens | Prime directive