Skip to content

Dreier Retirement Sets Off Scramble for Rules Gavel

Updated: 1:20 p.m.

The announced retirement of House Rules Chairman David Dreier (R-Calif.) this morning has opened up a power vacuum atop the influential committee, but as rumors of his imminent exit swirled for months, GOP leaders were quietly mulling who could replace him.

So far, two candidates for the job have risen to the top of the list to fill the Speaker-appointed post, according to several sources close to the issue. Those are two Members close to Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio): Rep. Pete Sessions (R-Texas), the second-ranking Republican on the Rules Committee, and Natural Resources Chairman Doc Hastings (R-Wash.).

“Pete Sessions has been there a long time,” Rep. Rob Bishop (R-Utah), a member of the Rules Committee, said Tuesday, just hours before Dreier’s announcement. “Doc Hastings was there a long time and is coming at the end of his cycle over at the committee at which he is, so you’ve got all sorts of options that are out there.”

When asked the day before he announced his retirement who could succeed him as chairman, Dreier said only, “If I were not here, it’s always the Speaker’s call.

“Anybody could fill my shoes,” he joked.

Of course, Dreier and every other Republican knows that is not the case.

One of the GOP’s most articulate and tactical minds, Dreier is renowned as a procedural maestro, going toe-to-toe with the committee ranking member Rep. Louise Slaughter (D-N.Y.) to bring difficult bills and amendments to the House floor.

Dreier, 59, this morning announced he would retire at the end of the term to join the private sector. He said he wanted to retire three years ago but stayed on to help as Republicans won the House majority.

“I have always believed that Republicans and Democrats alike serve the American people best when we find ways to build bipartisan consensus. The framers of our constitution envisioned Congress as a forum for a great clash of ideas. We all have different, sometimes radically different, views of how to build a better and stronger America. I have always believed that our efforts must be rooted in our pursuit of a free economy, personal freedom, limited government, and a strong national defense. Others may take a different view. These differences demand a passionate debate, but that debate must ultimately arrive at consensus,” Dreier said in a statement.

His decision this year was spurred along when the California Citizens Redistricting Commission carved up his district, leaving him with no clear constituency to represent. The 16-term lawmaker put up dismal fundraising numbers in the fourth quarter of 2011, hauling in just more than $10,000, making his retirement announcement just a matter of time.

Sources close to Boehner speculated that his first preference would be to install Sessions atop the committee. The move would not only reward the Texas lawmaker for his loyalty, but also avoid a high-profile leadership fight that almost happened just more than a year ago.

As chairman of the National Republican Congressional Committee, Sessions steered Republicans to a landslide win in the 2010 elections. But as Republicans took over the House majority, he mulled a run against Rep. Kevin McCarthy (Calif.) to be Whip. Boehner ultimately dissuaded him.

“Everyone recognizes the great job Rep. Sessions has done at the NRCC. Should he want to pursue the Rules chairmanship, his talents would be well utilized there,” said an aide with knowledge of the matter.

“As Chairman of the NRCC, all of my energy is focused on growing our Republican majority’s historic gains last election. It is an honor to serve as vice chairman of the Rules Committee under Chairman Dreier — a stalwart defender of Republican principles — and I would consider it a privilege to build upon my 14 years of service on the committee by continuing his legacy of tireless leadership and consummate professionalism,” Sessions said in a statement.

Sessions is also the conventional choice among his colleagues.

“Sessions seems to be the next person in line,” Rep. Tim Scott (R-S.C.), a freshman Member of leadership who sits on the Rules Committee, said Tuesday. “I would be surprised if it’s not him.”

When asked a day before Dreier’s announcement whether he would consider the chairmanship, Sessions said, “It’s entirely up to the Speaker.

“I’m now in my 14th year being on the Rules Committee, and it’s an exciting and wonderful place to be,” he added.

Boehner spokesman Michael Steel on Tuesday declined to answer specifics about the chairmanship, as Dreier had not yet announced his retirement.

“Chairman Dreier is the chairman on the Rules Committee. If he ever chooses to make a change, we’ll look at the options,” he said.

The NRCC chairmanship is traditionally a two-term job. But Sessions may have higher ambitions than the Rules gavel. If he does decide on a run for a premier leadership post, sources speculate that Boehner could turn to Hastings to helm the panel.

Hastings is in his second term as the top Republican on the Natural Resources Committee. But the Washington lawmaker, who served on the Rules Committee from 1997 to 2007 and is one of Boehner’s closest friends in the House, would be a natural choice to chair the Rules Committee.

While his current committee serves the interests of his home state exceptionally well, GOP rules limit Members to three terms as the top Republican on a panel, meaning that after the 113th Congress, he would be out in the cold. Although Boehner made an exception in allowing Dreier to keep his seat, there is no guarantee he would do the same for Hastings.

Hastings also was mum Tuesday on whether he is interested in another gavel.

“That’s the Speaker’s decision,” he said. “I’m not even speculating on any of that stuff.”

Correction: Feb. 29, 2011

An earlier version of this story incorrectly stated the number of years Rep. Doc Hastings served on the House Rules Committee. He served on the committee from 1997 to 2007.

Recent Stories

‘Ready for the fight’: After narrow loss in 2022, Logan aims for Hayes’ Connecticut House seat

Strange things are afoot at the Capitol

Photos of the week ending May 24, 2024

Getting down on the Senate floor — Congressional Hits and Misses

US-China tech race will determine values that shape the future

What’s at stake in Texas runoff elections on Tuesday